Tears, emotion as family see spot where Imam Haron allegedly fell, cells he was held in

Tvivash Moodley, an expert witness in the Imam Haron inquest, explains to the Judge how it was alleged that Imam Haron fell to his death on this staircase at the Cape Town Central Police station. An in loco inspection took place on Tuesday at Cape Town Central and Maitland Police Stations as part of the re-opened inquest into the death of anti-Apartheid cleric Imam Abdullah Haron. Picture: Ian Landsberg

Tvivash Moodley, an expert witness in the Imam Haron inquest, explains to the Judge how it was alleged that Imam Haron fell to his death on this staircase at the Cape Town Central Police station. An in loco inspection took place on Tuesday at Cape Town Central and Maitland Police Stations as part of the re-opened inquest into the death of anti-Apartheid cleric Imam Abdullah Haron. Picture: Ian Landsberg

Published Nov 9, 2022

Share

Cape Town - There were tears and emotional scenes as the family of anti-apartheid Struggle activist Imam Abdullah Haron visited the police cells and the stairway where the imam was alleged to have had the fall which led to his death.

Surrounded by friends and relatives, as well as court officials and journalists, the imam’s three children Muhammed, Fatiema and Shamila Haron stoically tried to contain their emotions during the visit, but at times found it impossible to stop the tears.

The visit was part of an inspection in loco by Judge Daniel Thulare, who is presiding over the inquest, and took in Cape Town Central police station (formerly Caledon Square police station) and the Maitland police station.

These were the two police stations where Imam Haron was kept and tortured during his 123 days in police custody. He was later found dead in his cell at Maitland police station.

Outside the cells, Nkosinathi Biko, CEO of the Steve Biko Foundation and a friend of the Haron family, spoke of the emotional wrench the family was experiencing as they saw the cells where their father was held and the staircase he allegedly fell down.

“It’s a very emotive moment. And I can only imagine what the family are going through because for many of them it will be the first time they will have seen these places.”

Members of the Imam Haron family on the staircase where he fell. Picture: MWANGI GITHAHU/Cape Argus
Imam Haron’s son, Muhammed Haron has a moment. Picture by MWANGI GITHAHU/Cape Argus
Members of Imam Haron’s family with Nkosinathi Biko outside the Maitland police station where Imam Haron was found dead. Picture: MWANGI GITHAHU/Cape Argus

Remembering his own experience, Biko said the apartheid security police had three regular explanations for deaths that occurred in custody and these were that the person died by suicide, fell down the stairs or slipped on a bar of soap.

During the visit to Cape Town Central police station, aeronautical engineer and trajectory expert Thivash Moodley dramatically demonstrated how the apartheid police alleged Imam Haron fell down the stairs.

In the original inquest, apartheid security branch police officers Johannes “Spyker” van Wyk and Dirk Genis claimed Haron slipped, fell backwards and slid down the stairs and stopped two or three steps from the bottom.

When the inquest returned to the courtroom, Moodley gave evidence based on his technical assessment report of Imam Haron’s alleged fall.

Moodley said: “If Haron had fallen backwards on the highest step when he supposedly landed, he would have most likely landed on the landing located on the bend, and may not have slid down the stairs.”

Aeronautical Engineer Thivash Moodely’s demonstration of how Imam Haron allegedly fell. Tvivash Moodley, an expert witness in the Imam Haron inquest, explains to the Judge how it was alleged that Imam Haron fell to his death on this staircase. Picture: Mwangi Githahu/Cape Argus
Aeronautical Engineer Thivash Moodely in the courtroom. Picture: by MWANGI GITHAHU/Cape Argus

“Given that there is no bruising on the buttocks, the back, aside from the small circular bruise on the back, neck or head, and considering the magnitude of the impact velocities that Haron’s body parts would have struck the stairs with, the police version that all Haron’s injuries were sustained during a fall down a staircase is, in my opinion, not credible.”

He said in contrast, there were significant injuries on Haron’s chest, inner-right thigh and calf, both shins and left hamstring which could not be connected to the alleged fall.

The inquest continues.

During the in loco visit to Maitland police station. Picture: MWANGI GITHAHU/Cape Argus

[email protected]

Cape Argus